Stories
Stories
Clay Christensen on Competing Against Luck
Why They Buy
The first big puzzle Professor Clay Christensen tackled when he joined the HBS faculty in 1992 was an elemental one: Why was success so hard for businesses to sustain? The search led to his theory of disruptive innovation, which would eventually result in the much-heralded The Innovator’s Dilemma and make “disruption” a universal buzzword. Christensen’s latest book, Competing Against Luck, drops this month and is an outgrowth of the second puzzle he’s faced: Why is innovation such a gamble? It doesn’t have to be, says Christensen. Here he talks about the alternative the book outlines—the “theory of jobs to be done”—and how that concept might play out in the auto industry.
—Dan Morrell
Your theory essentially reframes how managers think about their products or services—as a sort of job that the customer is trying to fulfill. In those terms, what job is this book fulfilling for readers?
I hope readers will say to themselves, “Oh my gosh, I can predict whether this product is going to be successful in the market. It actually is not a crapshoot.” And if the theory helps you predict with much more clarity that it is not going to work, think about how much cost and time you do not waste. I hope it truly brings predictability to innovation that historically we just have not had before.
Why do managers ignore the motivations of their customers? Is part of it because they are now awash with data and fetishize it to a certain extent?
I am hoping the answer is that we just have not taught managers and marketers we have a problem, and so, if you think that more data will solve the problem of what is not in the data, then we are misleading people in a serious way.
How would cars work as an example of a job that customers need to get done?
Car companies have structured the market so that they think of it as product categories. You have full-size, midsize, compact, subcompact, minivan, SUVs, crossovers—as if categories cause people to buy products.
My calculation is that about 30 percent of all cars sold are sold as an office, because there are people who have to work on the road—there are salespeople, there are service people. They have to have access to data, they have to communicate. When I have that job to be done and I do not have a physical office to go to, what do I do? What can I hire to do the job of an office? When I was a sales guy, I could hire McDonald’s to do the job. I would get a Diet Coke and sit at the back tables and figure out where I was and what I was going to do next and who I needed to call. But sometimes, I have no option. I have to hire my car to be an office. But nobody has designed a car to serve as an office. And so what would you do if Ford said, “Boy, we could take the car as is, but the cockpit would be very different if we conceive of it as a job.” Imagine the differentiation that it would bring to Ford. It is not just a compact anymore.
Christensen reveals how his theories have shaped his teaching and home life on the new podcast Skydeck at alumni.hbs.edu/podcast
Post a Comment
Related Stories
-
- 01 Jun 2025
- HBS Magazine
Alumni and Faculty Books
Re: Charley Ellis (MBA 1963); Maria Ellis (OPM 32); Anson Frericks (MBA 2011); Don Gillis (PMD 66); P.J. Kirby (MBA 1978); Larry Lepard (MBA 1983); Mike Mears (MBA 1975); John Travers (MBA 2002); Lee Wilson (MBA 1978); Matthew C. Weinzierl (Joseph and Jacqueline Elbling Professor of Business Administration Senior Associate Dean, Chair, MBA Program); Julia B. Austin (Senior Lecturer of Business Administration); Arthur C. Brooks (Professor of Management Practice); Ranjay Gulati (Paul R. Lawrence MBA Class of 1942 Professor of Business Administration); Gunnar Trumbull (Philip Caldwell Professor of Business Administration) -
- 01 Mar 2025
- HBS Magazine
Alumni and Faculty Books
Re: Chinwe Ajene (MBA 2003); Andrew Brodsky (PHDOB 2017); Brian Buxton (MBA 1977); Kweilin Ellingrud (MBA 2005); Anne Fonte (MBA 1992); Steve Ossad (MBA 1976); Aaron Poynton (AMP 195); Gregory Slayton (MBA 1990); Karen Swanson (MBA 1990); Teresa M. Amabile (Edsel Bryant Ford Professor of Business Administration, Emerita); Alison Wood Brooks (O'Brien Associate Professor of Business Administration); Jeffrey J. Bussgang (Senior Lecturer of Business Administration); Prithwiraj Choudhury (Lumry Family Associate Professor of Business Administration) -
- 15 Dec 2024
- HBS Magazine
Alumni and Faculty Books
Re: Kavita Bhatnagar (SELP 11); Amar Bhide (MBA 1979); Siri Chilazi (MBA 2016); Christopher Cox (MBA 1997); Gurcharan Das (AMP 91); Maria Ellis (OPM 32); Brooks Fenno (MBA 1962); Sue Hemphill (PMD 47); Frank Lorenzo (MBA 1963); John Lotz (MBA 1971); Ron May (AMP 165); Rusty McClure (MBA 1975); Allie Nava (MBA 2002); Wilbur Ross (MBA 1961); Garry Sanderson (AMP 175); Ken Wilcox (MBA 1983); Rick Williams (PMD 33); Michael Horn (MBA 2006); Max H. Bazerman (Jesse Isidor Straus Professor of Business Administration); Ethan S. Bernstein (Edward W. Conard Associate Professor of Business Administration); Malcolm S. Salter (James J. Hill Professor of Business Administration, Emeritus); Feng Zhu (MBA Class of 1958 Professor of Business Administration) -
- 01 Sep 2024
- HBS Alumni Bulletin
Ink: Framing the Full Picture
Re: Amy Chu (MBA 1999); By: Jen McFarland Flint
